FERRARI 458
Ferrari 458
December 7, 2009 4:45 PM  |  Posted By: HenryCatchpole
Rated 3.3 out of 5.0 by 3 members  |  18 Comments  |  4315 Views
Related Categories: Ferrari

I don’t think Ferraris are cars you simply like or admire, they seem to ignite something in your soul that means you will defend them to the hilt, allow subjectivity to lord it over objectivity and overlook all the obvious Italianisms. Which brings us to the 458 Italia. I haven’t seen one in all its carbon/aluminium fleshiness yet, let alone driven one. And yet… I’m not sure about it. I know it’s going to be brilliant (I obviously trust Harris’s judgement on that), but that’s half the problem. I preferred the gritty, battling Ferrari F1 team of the early ‘90s with Mansell, Berger and Alesi wringing the most from the V12 compared to the assured confidence of the Schumacher era.

I think my worries are encapsulated by the 458’s switch to a DSG gearbox. I liked the fact that Ferrari was swimming against the tide of cog-swapping opinion and persevering with the automated manual. The F1 SuperFast2 system in the Scuderia was mind-blowing but adding to the excitement was the almost palpable sense that it was slightly fragile and could go bang in a cloud of oil and mistimed gears.

Then there’s the switchgear on the 458 steering wheel. I mean someone’s actually thought about that instead of designing the whole car and then butchering the indicator stalks from a handy Punto and shoving them into the steering column moments before unveiling it to the public.

I want an Italian supercar to have a sense of seat-of-the-pants engineering. They shouldn’t be flawless and ‘useable everyday’… should they?

 
Add Comment  |  Bookmark and Share  | 

Rating:

COMMENTS
 

xeviuus at 7:55 PM February 2, 2010

yea paddle shifters are great about 0.1% of time for me. (that's how much i guestimated i take my scuderia f1 to the track). it's a blast but on the road back and forth driving in the streets, i really don't like it. meanwhile i love my 599 in 6 speed in the streets (although dreadful in the track in my hands). too bad that those beautiful gated shifter would be gone forever. there are something sweet about clinking of the gates when you shift. i think some of ferrari magic was there...

JamesAsh at 3:31 PM February 1, 2010

The more supercars become like driving on a computer game, and the less they feel like they're going to kill you at every moment, the less excited I get about them. Who here would take a Veyron over a McLaren F1? Surely one of the best things about driving a performance car is the pleasure derived from feeling you actually make some difference.... you kept yourself out of that hedge... you read the camber over the road coming up and took evasive action.... you made that braking zone so sweet by matching the revs absolutely perfectly. Things that are perfect are only endearing if they have a human quality - by which I mean a perfect blipped downshift which takes a fraction of a second will make you respect the car and the engineers who made it. But watching a really good driver do it first-hand in a difficult car will make you think he is God.

vvvrally at 1:29 AM January 23, 2010

I agree that Ferrari should do a smaller lighter 'Dino' for the modern era...the model range has unfortunately gone in the direction of bloated GT instead...leave that to the Germans or Brits phps. Don't agree that unreliability is a formula to aspire to, 'Italianess' is something inherently found in Italian design...even reliable ones, and we're not talking Gallardo either here as that's an Audi....its about fine geometry and the art of sound....a sensory journey - this needn't include sitting on the shoulder waiting for a tow...the pain should be in the price of entry - as looks to be the case with the 458.

turbobungle at 2:44 PM January 22, 2010

I agree with SD about possibly not getting excited about the 458 like we do the 288 GTO and F40 but the 458 is the equivalent to the 308 and 328, the GTO and F40's modern equivalents are the Enzo and 599GTO! As for the Italianism's, I'm not convinced build quality and reliability can take the shine off of Ferrari ownership. When I drove my F355 Spider across France, roof down, sun shining, fantastic roads, ITO Race exhaust screaming at 117db I was in Ferrari heaven! The heavens then opened up and all the people I'd overtaken with a smile on my face were laughing and pointing at me on my hands and knees trying to work out why the roof was now half erected and refusing to move in either direction while the rain continued to fill my exepensive red bathtub! Trust me, that's not a good part of the Ferrari experience!!

Matt at 2:15 PM January 19, 2010

I don't like dsg, it performs an action in shifting that feel less natural than automated manuals. I hope it will be great dsg, better than the porsche one.

Visceral1111 at 8:35 PM December 13, 2009

Mr. Catchpole!! Great blog post.

gangajas at 11:30 AM December 11, 2009

I guess we can assume which car is going to win the next eCOTY. The new 911 GT3 RS, for being more involving than the Ferrari (some lyricism about heel&toe downshifts while applying a dab of oppo included)at a fraction of the price. Kind of a déjà vu.

HenryCatchpole at 8:20 PM December 10, 2009

Hmm, interesting. Perhaps the tone was a little too floridly nostalgic (hence, probably, the sense of stereotyping). So, lets put it this way I'm worried that the 458 is going to be a little too polished. Contrary to what I seem to have implied, I wasn't saying that I want the car to break down at the first sign of a light drizzle, but I am worried that the driving experience might feel a bit too smooth, might have lost some tangible character thanks to the ever increasing use of electronic wizardry. It probably won't, of course. It'll probably be raw as a French steak and bloody lovely.

tab75xl at 1:16 PM December 9, 2009

So you'd prefer it if it was a bit less good? These new cars aren't as good because they break down less than the old ones? If the driving experience is less thrilling than the 430 then judge it on that; otherwise this is the sort of claptrap I'd expect from a classic car magazine.

aerorobnz at 5:29 AM December 9, 2009

It's supposed to be bespoke. I'm not saying I wouldn't go for an F1 gearbox, but Ferrari have made a big deal about the Atelier personalisation scheme on the 612/599/California and the choice of manual gearbox should still be available if I am prepared to fork out the cash for it as an option just as I would have done with the F1 gearbox in the 355/360/575 days...

Ayo0 at 10:20 PM December 8, 2009

If I was going to spend that kind of money on a car, it should be usable and reliable. I think Ferrari are on the right track.

David_Yu at 11:34 AM December 8, 2009

I don't think you'll find any Ferrari owners have put "potential unreliability" or "poor switchgear" at the top of their reasons why they love their cars. Ferrari have stayed at the top of the tree by offering a few key things better than most other marques: Looks, Noise, Performance (through technology) and Handling. I simply don't buy into "it needs flaws to have character" ethos, hence why I am equally happy in my GT-R.

Darklogic at 8:20 AM December 8, 2009

Is there room for passion anymore in a world with computerized everything and the ability to simulate fluid and chassis dynamics? I suppose the traditional car is at the very edge of what's possible. Let's have a new paradigm shift please!

Ingenere at 5:08 AM December 8, 2009

I have been a Ferrari owner for the better part of 25 years, and it has been a long time since the Maranello boys have actually managed to draw a good looking car. I have to admit the 458 looks the part. I am sure the performance is brilliant. I just hope that they haven't engineered the 'Italianess" out, as that is all part of the experience.

Gav_GT at 2:40 AM December 8, 2009

I think modern motoring has become far too refined nowadays. The rawness of everything seems to be dissipating.

gangajas at 1:43 AM December 8, 2009

Any other stereotype you want to add to your blog entry?

Al at 10:28 PM December 7, 2009

Is it a supercar? Surely the Enzo and FXX are supercars. I'm not sure where that leaves the 458, and I'd rather see Ferrari do something simpler and lighter. (i.e. a new Dino) I did think it looked stunning in photos initially, but then saw a photo of it next to an Evora and preferred the Evora, from the front at least.

Stephen Dobie at 5:12 PM December 7, 2009

I've got to agree. Can't see me getting excited about it in decades to come like I do the F40 and 288 now. 458 still looks ace, mind...

Login to post a comment.

MEMBER LOGIN

|
Company Website | Media Information | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Privacy Statement | Subs Info
Our Other Websites: Auto Express | Computer Buyer | Computer Shopper | Custom PC | Den of Geek | Den of Wii | Fortean Times | IT Pro
Know Your Mobile | London is Free | MacUser | Men's Fitness | Micro Mart | Mobile Computer | Octane | PC Pro | The First Post | iGizmo
iMotor | DigitalSLR photography | bit-tech